Difficulty: Hard

Average Score: 0%

Which supervisor's action can invalidate the appraisal instrument?

Rationale

Monitoring computers to gather information without employees' knowledge can invalidate the appraisal instrument.

This action violates ethical standards of transparency and consent, undermining the integrity of the appraisal process. When supervisors collect information in secret, it can lead to mistrust and a lack of accountability, ultimately rendering the appraisal results invalid.

A (Using an informal communication style to deliver the information) YOUR ANSWER

While the communication style may affect how feedback is perceived, it does not inherently invalidate the appraisal instrument. Informal communication can still convey important performance insights and does not breach ethical guidelines or trust, as long as the content remains relevant and constructive.

B (Monitoring computers to gather information without employees' knowledge) CORRECT

This choice is the correct answer because it breaches ethical standards concerning privacy and consent. Monitoring employees without their knowledge can lead to feelings of betrayal and suspicion, undermining the validity of any appraisal that relies on such covert information-gathering methods.

C (Sharing the data with the employee's colleague) YOUR ANSWER

Although sharing appraisal data may breach confidentiality and trust, it does not necessarily invalidate the appraisal instrument itself. The integrity of the instrument is more directly affected by how information is collected rather than shared, assuming the data was obtained ethically.

D (Lacking the skills to give good feedback) YOUR ANSWER

While a supervisor's inability to provide effective feedback can diminish the quality of the appraisal, it does not invalidate the appraisal process itself. Appraisals can still be conducted even if the feedback is poorly delivered, as the validity of the instrument primarily pertains to the collection of data rather than the delivery method.

Conclusion

In summary, the action that can invalidate the appraisal instrument is the unethical practice of monitoring employees without their knowledge. This violates principles of transparency, erodes trust, and can fundamentally compromise the appraisal's validity. Other options may lead to poor execution or communication but do not affect the ethical integrity of the appraisal process itself.

Related Questions

View all