Oncologist did not disclose 70% mortality rate to IRB. Which ethical principle violated?
Veracity was violated by the oncologist's failure to disclose the 70% mortality rate to the IRB.
Veracity, or truthfulness, is a fundamental ethical principle in healthcare that requires practitioners to provide accurate and complete information. By not disclosing the mortality rate, the oncologist undermined the trust that is essential in the patient-care provider relationship and the integrity of the research process.
Justice refers to the ethical principle of fairness and equality, particularly in the distribution of benefits and burdens in research and healthcare. While failing to disclose information may affect fairness indirectly, it primarily pertains to the truthfulness of the information provided rather than the equitable treatment of individuals or groups.
Conflict of interest involves situations where personal interests might compromise professional judgment. Although the oncologist's failure to disclose the mortality rate could imply a lack of transparency, it does not directly relate to a conflict between personal gain and professional responsibility. The issue here is primarily about honesty rather than conflicting motivations.
Beneficence is the obligation to act in the best interest of patients and to promote their welfare. While the omission of the mortality rate may have implications for patient safety, the principle that is most directly violated by failing to provide critical information is veracity, as it pertains to the accuracy and honesty of the information shared.
Veracity is the ethical principle that demands honesty in communication with patients and research participants. By not disclosing the 70% mortality rate, the oncologist compromised the integrity of the informed consent process, which relies on accurate information to ensure that participants can make well-informed decisions regarding their involvement in research.
In summary, the oncologist's failure to disclose the 70% mortality rate to the IRB constitutes a violation of the principle of veracity. This breach of truthfulness undermines trust in the medical and research communities and compromises the ethical foundation of informed consent. While other principles like justice, conflict of interest, and beneficence are important, the core issue in this scenario is the lack of honesty in communication.
Related Questions
View allA hospital administrator has observed excess readmissions… How should...
Numerous studies show that patients want to have conversations about t...
Prior to hand hygiene initiative, staff reviewed existing materials (p...
There have been recent complaints at a pharmacy… administrator decides...
Office manager assessing patient no-show rate over past month. Which d...
Related Quizzes
View all0PC1 Planning Instructional Strategies for Meaningful Learning Version 1
AP01 Elementary Literacy Curriculum Version 1
AQ01 Applied Healthcare Statistics C784 Version 1
ASO1 Introduction to Statistics for Research Version 1
BJ01 Introduction to Business Finance Version 1
C172 Network and Security Foundations Version 1
C180 Introduction to Psychology Version 1
C180 Introduction to Psychology Version 2
CKC1 Introduction to Humanities Version 1
DZ01 Mathematics for Elementary Educators III MATH 1330 Version 1
- ✓ 500+ Practice Questions
- ✓ Detailed Explanations
- ✓ Progress Analytics
- ✓ Exam Simulations