Difficulty: Medium

Average Score: 66%

Which one of the following is misleading information that Alice uses to support her argument that the house is "terrifying"?

Rationale

The basement having a dirt floor is misleading information that Alice uses to support her argument that the house is "terrifying".

The presence of a dirt floor in the basement does not inherently make a house terrifying. While it may be considered outdated or possibly unhygienic, it does not necessarily contribute to a sense of fear or terror.

A (The basement has a dirt floor) CORRECT

While a dirt floor could be a sign of an older or poorly maintained house, it doesn't necessarily make the house "terrifying". It may contribute to a sense of discomfort or dissatisfaction, but it is misleading to use this as evidence of terror.

B (There are glass jars on the shelves in the basement) YOUR ANSWER

The presence of glass jars on shelves in the basement is not inherently terrifying. These could simply be used for storage or preservation purposes, which is a common practice in many households. Using this as an argument to support the house being terrifying is not misleading.

C (The doors and floors are original to the home) YOUR ANSWER

The originality of the doors and floors could suggest that the house is old, but this doesn't make it terrifying. In fact, many people value and appreciate the original features of a home as they can add character and historical value. Therefore, this is not misleading information to support the claim that the house is terrifying.

D (The doors and floors are original to the home) YOUR ANSWER

As stated above, having original doors and floors doesn't make a house terrifying. This point is identical to option C and provides the same reasoning – it cannot be classified as misleading information that supports the claim of the house being terrifying.

Conclusion

Misleading information in an argument is information that is used to support a claim but does not logically or inherently prove the claim. In this case, Alice's claim that the house is "terrifying" is not supported by the fact that the basement has a dirt floor. This point, while perhaps indicating the house's age or lack of modern updates, does not directly correlate to a sense of terror. Therefore, it is misleading information in the context of her argument.

Related Questions

View all