Difficulty: Medium

Average Score: 60%

BUTTERBEAN FOR MAYOR
Butterbean wants to be YOUR new mayor. Is there an election coming? No. Can dogs even be mayors? Unclear. But consider what Butterbean has to offer:
• FRIENDS WITH EVERYONE
Big dogs. Small dogs. In-between dogs. All the people. If you go for walks, you've met Butterbean and she loves you.
• JUST A REGULAR DOG
Butterbean is a regular dog for regular folks. She's not a fancy breed, just a dog. Sure, maybe she eats more socks than her vet recommends, but nobody's perfect.
• .HATES RATS
You hate rats. Butterbean hates rats, too. She will not rest until they have all been chased from our streets. By her, personally.
Can Butterbean count on YOUR vote? Or at least a treat?

Which of the following ideas, if added to the text, would make the passage more persuasive?

Rationale

The author proves that dogs can be mayors by citing examples where dogs were elected as mayor.

Including evidence that dogs have been elected as mayors in other instances would lend credibility to Butterbean's candidacy and appeal to readers' emotions by showcasing successful canine leadership.

A (The author proves that the city has a rat problem that people cannot solve) YOUR ANSWER

While demonstrating a rat problem may emphasize Butterbean's dedication to chasing them away, it does not directly support her capability or legitimacy as a candidate. This point focuses more on the issue than on why Butterbean should be elected, making it less persuasive in the context of her campaign.

B (The author provides data on how many visits to the veterinarian for eating socks Butterbean has made) YOUR ANSWER

Although this information could add a humorous element to the narrative, it detracts from Butterbean's qualifications for mayor. This detail does not reinforce her suitability for leadership and may instead raise concerns about her behavior, rendering it irrelevant for persuading voters.

C (The author proves that dogs can be mayors by citing examples where dogs were elected as mayor) CORRECT

Citing real-world examples of canine mayors would effectively validate Butterbean's bid for office. This addition would not only strengthen her case but also inspire confidence in voters by illustrating that dogs can hold positions of authority and responsibility.

D (The author provides a graph that shows the popularity of “regular' dogs vs. pedugreed dogs) YOUR ANSWER

While this information might be interesting, it fails to directly contribute to Butterbean's qualifications or appeal. Popularity comparisons between dog types do not address her specific capabilities or suggest why she would be a good mayor, making it less persuasive to potential voters.

Conclusion

To enhance the persuasive nature of the passage, citing examples of dogs that have successfully assumed roles as mayors would provide a strong rationale for Butterbean's candidacy. Such evidence would not only validate the concept of a dog in leadership but also resonate with readers emotionally, thereby increasing the likelihood of garnering support for her campaign.

Related Questions

View all