Difficulty: Medium

Average Score: 67%

What was one of John Wernicke's criticisms of the analytic introspection method?

Rationale

The method produced extremely variable results from person to person.

John Wernicke criticized the analytic introspection method for yielding highly inconsistent and divergent outcomes when applied across different individuals. This variability undermined the reliability and reproducibility of the method's findings, hindering its utility in generating generalizable conclusions about mental processes.

A (The method was used to study questions of philosophy rather than psychology.) YOUR ANSWER

This statement inaccurately attributes the criticism to the focus of study rather than the method's inherent limitations. Wernicke's critique centered on the unreliability of results, not the subject matter under investigation.

B (The method produced narrow results that were easy to manipulate.) YOUR ANSWER

Contrary to this choice, Wernicke's criticism did not revolve around the narrowness or manipulability of outcomes but rather the wide variability observed among different participants undergoing analytic introspection.

C (The method produced extremely variable results from person to person.) CORRECT

Correct. Wernicke's primary objection to analytic introspection was the inconsistency in results obtained when different individuals engaged in the process. This variability made it challenging to draw definitive conclusions about mental phenomena based on introspective reports.

D (The method was used to study questions with no relevance or validity.) YOUR ANSWER

This option misinterprets Wernicke's criticism by suggesting that he questioned the relevance or validity of the topics studied via analytic introspection. In reality, his concern lay with the unreliability of the method's outcomes rather than the nature of the questions themselves.

Conclusion

John Wernicke's critique of the analytic introspection method centered on the significant variability in results observed among different individuals practicing introspection. This inconsistency in outcomes weakened the method's credibility and hindered its effectiveness in generating consistent and reliable insights into psychological processes. By highlighting the unreliability of introspective reports, Wernicke contributed to the ongoing debate regarding the utility and limitations of introspection as a scientific tool in psychology.

Related Questions

View all