Difficulty: Hard

Average Score: 35%

Which of the following sentences is grammatically correct with a misplaced modifier?

Rationale

The child's torn shirt was lying on the floor.

This sentence is grammatically correct and contains a misplaced modifier that does not obscure the meaning. The phrase "torn shirt" correctly describes the shirt belonging to the child, allowing for clarity and proper interpretation.

A (The child's torn shirt was lying on the floor) CORRECT

This sentence is correct because it clearly indicates that the shirt is torn and belongs to the child. The modifier "torn" appropriately describes "shirt," ensuring that the sentence conveys its intended meaning without ambiguity.

B (The torn child's shirt was lying on the floor) YOUR ANSWER

This construction suggests that the child is torn rather than the shirt. The placement of the modifier "torn" before "child" creates confusion, implying that the child has been torn, which is not the intended meaning of the sentence.

C (The child's shirt was lying on the floor torn) YOUR ANSWER

The positioning of "torn" at the end of this sentence leads to awkward phrasing and confusion. It suggests that the action of lying on the floor is what makes the shirt torn, rather than describing the state of the shirt itself.

D (The child's shirt, torn, was lying on the floor) YOUR ANSWER

While this sentence is grammatically correct, it uses a nonrestrictive modifier. The phrase "torn" adds extra information but does not create the misplaced modifier effect intended in the question. Thus, it does not fulfill the requirement of having a misplaced modifier as asked.

Conclusion

In summary, the sentence "The child's torn shirt was lying on the floor" is grammatically correct and effectively conveys that the shirt is torn. The other options either misplace the modifier or lead to awkward or incorrect interpretations, illustrating the importance of modifier placement in sentence clarity.

Related Questions

View all