Difficulty: Hard

Average Score: 49%

Which of the following sentences is grammatically correct? (misplaced modifier)

Rationale

The child's torn shirt was lying on the floor.

This sentence is grammatically correct because it clearly conveys that the shirt, which belongs to the child, is torn and is located on the floor. The modifier "torn" is correctly placed before the noun "shirt," providing a clear and logical description.

A (The child's torn shirt was lying on the floor) CORRECT

This option is grammatically correct as it maintains a clear structure, placing the modifier "torn" directly before the noun "shirt." This positioning ensures that the meaning is straightforward and unambiguous, indicating that the shirt, not the child, is torn.

B (The torn child's shirt was lying on the floor) YOUR ANSWER

This sentence is incorrect due to a misplaced modifier. It implies that the child is torn, which is not the intended meaning. The structure confuses the relationship between the child and the shirt, leading to a misunderstanding of what is being described.

C (The child's shirt was lying on the floor torn) YOUR ANSWER

This option is also incorrect because the placement of the modifier "torn" at the end of the sentence creates confusion. It suggests that the action of lying down is what is torn, rather than the shirt itself, resulting in awkward phrasing and a lack of clarity.

D (The child's shirt, torn, was lying on the floor) YOUR ANSWER

While this sentence is not grammatically incorrect, it is less effective than option A. The use of commas around "torn" creates a parenthetical element that may imply that the shirt's condition is less essential to the sentence. This can lead to a less direct description, which diminishes the clarity of the imagery.

Conclusion

In summary, option A is the only clear and grammatically correct sentence that effectively conveys the intended meaning without ambiguity. Proper placement of modifiers is crucial for clarity in writing, ensuring that the reader understands exactly what is being described. Options B, C, and D fail to achieve this clarity, making them grammatically incorrect or awkwardly phrased.

Related Questions

View all