Difficulty: Easy

Average Score: 100%

Which of the following is the best example of negative transfer?

Rationale

Juan mispronounces an English word based on the pronunciation of a similar word in his native language.

Negative transfer occurs when prior learning interferes with the acquisition of new skills or knowledge. In this case, Juan's mispronunciation exemplifies how his native language's phonetic rules negatively impact his ability to pronounce an English word correctly.

A (Sarah notices no improvement in her basketball skills after lifting weights for several weeks.) YOUR ANSWER

This scenario describes a lack of improvement rather than a negative transfer. It suggests that Sarah's weightlifting might not effectively translate to her basketball skills, but it doesn’t indicate that her previous experience is causing interference with her learning.

B (Marissa is scolded for using a measuring tool incorrectly, and she remembers to use it correctly the next time.) YOUR ANSWER

This example illustrates positive transfer, where Marissa learns from her mistake and applies the correct method in future situations. It does not demonstrate any interference from previous learning but rather a successful adjustment.

C (Amir learns a basic subtraction skill in math class and later uses the skill when shopping in a store.) YOUR ANSWER

This scenario highlights positive transfer as well, where Amir effectively applies his learned subtraction skills in a real-world context. It shows how prior knowledge enhances his ability to perform new tasks rather than hinders it.

D (Juan mispronounces an English word based on the pronunciation of a similar word in his native language.) CORRECT

Juan's example clearly illustrates negative transfer, as the phonetic similarities between languages lead to incorrect pronunciation in English. This interference from his native language's rules directly obstructs his ability to learn and use the correct English pronunciation.

Conclusion

Negative transfer can significantly impede learning by allowing previously acquired knowledge to interfere with new information. In this case, Juan’s mispronunciation due to his native language exemplifies how such interference can occur, contrasting with the other scenarios that illustrate positive transfer or lack of impact on learning. Understanding these concepts is essential for effective teaching and learning strategies.

Related Questions

View all