Which of the following, if true, most weakens the support the experimental results provide for the researchers' conclusion?
During the experiment, the volunteers who were experiencing more sinus congestion than average tended to substantially reduce, or even stop, their dairy consumption as a result.
This statement weakens the researchers' conclusion by suggesting that the observed lack of increased sinus congestion among high dairy consumers may be due to a behavioral change in those experiencing congestion, rather than an actual effect of dairy consumption on sinus congestion.
This choice directly challenges the conclusion by indicating that individuals with more congestion might have altered their dairy intake. If those with greater congestion are consuming less dairy, it could explain why high dairy consumers did not show increased congestion, thereby undermining the assertion that dairy does not affect congestion.
While this statement provides context about the volunteers' consumption habits, it does not directly address the impact of dairy on sinus congestion. It does not weaken the conclusion because it does not imply a causal relationship between dairy and congestion; rather, it simply describes the participants' consumption patterns.
This option suggests that reducing dairy intake does not lead to reduced congestion, but it does not comment on the comparison between high and low dairy consumers. Therefore, it does not weaken the conclusion regarding the effects of dairy consumption on sinus congestion.
This statement provides information about prior health patterns but does not affect the current experiment's findings. It does not weaken the conclusion because it does not address the relationship between current dairy consumption and sinus congestion during colds.
While this indicates variability in congestion, it does not directly challenge the conclusion since it does not imply that dairy consumption affects congestion levels. Thus, it does not weaken the researchers' assertion about dairy's influence.
The argument presented by the researchers hinges on the assumption that dairy consumption has no effect on sinus congestion in cold sufferers. Choice A introduces a significant counterpoint, suggesting that individuals with increased congestion may reduce dairy intake, thereby skewing the results and undermining the conclusion. Other options either provide additional context or do not directly impact the assertion, leaving A as the strongest choice to weaken the conclusion.
Related Questions
View allIt can be inferred that the author assumes which of the following in a...
The passage most strongly suggests that which of the following stateme...
Which of the following, if true, would most contribute to strengthenin...
Which of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the discrepancy...
The passage claims that RNA interference could lead to TKS becoming a...
Related Quizzes
View allGmat Quantitative Reasoning Practice Questions
Quantitative Reasoning GMAT
Gmat Quantitative Reasoning Practice
Official Gmat Data Insights Practice Questions
GMAT 2025 Exam Changes Verbal Reasoning
GMAT Exam Changes 2025 March 5 Verbal Reasoning
- ✓ 500+ Practice Questions
- ✓ Detailed Explanations
- ✓ Progress Analytics
- ✓ Exam Simulations