Difficulty: Easy

Average Score: 76%

Acme Builder constructs a cement driveway for Mrs. Bee… The homeowner has no legal obligation to pay for the increase because the

Rationale

Contractor failed to prepare a change order to the contract and have the homeowner sign it.

In construction law, a change order is essential for any modifications to the original contract, including adjustments in cost. Since the contractor did not secure a signed change order for the increase in the driveway's width, the homeowner is not legally required to pay the additional cost.

A (contractor failed to properly estimate the cost in the contract.) YOUR ANSWER

While accurate cost estimation is essential for contract fulfillment, the legal obligation to pay arises from the terms agreed upon in the contract itself. If the contractor underestimated costs but did not have a signed change order, this does not create an obligation for the homeowner to pay for increases.

C (homeowner would not have had easy access to the garage without the additional width.) YOUR ANSWER

Although practical considerations, such as access, may influence project decisions, they do not alter the contractual obligations between the contractor and homeowner. The homeowner's needs do not exempt the contractor from the requirement to formalize changes through a signed change order.

D (contractor will be able to increase the price on his next job to make up the loss.) YOUR ANSWER

This statement pertains to the contractor's future business practices and does not reflect the current legal situation regarding the contract with Mrs. Bee. The homeowner is not liable for unapproved costs, regardless of the contractor's ability to adjust pricing in future projects.

Conclusion

In construction agreements, proper adherence to contract terms, including the necessity of signed change orders for any adjustments, is crucial. In this scenario, since the contractor failed to obtain a signed change order for the increase, the homeowner is under no legal obligation to pay for the additional costs associated with the driveway modification. Understanding these requirements helps ensure fair and enforceable agreements in construction projects.

Related Questions

View all